icann at large home register here members charter forum voting history progress statements funding regional links

Results

Original question:

If you voted for option B (division of powers),

Do you want a separate 3 person membership committee, tasked with maintaining the members' list and determining who is a member in accordance with our constitution?

YES/NO/ something else (please use the comment line)

Electing a membership committee

Total number of voters: 64
Vote Number of Votes Percentage
NO 12 18.7500%
something else (use comment line) 5 7.8125%
YES 47 73.4375%

Comments:
  • I don't know how much work maintaining this list would be. My instinct is that it's not enough for a whole committee, though, that it should be the responsibility of someone on the panel.
  • but not determining who is a member
  • I want an elected Secretary of the organization, whose duties include responsibility for the membership roster. Some of the work can be delegated; responsibility cannot.
  • This depends on what the constitutional standard for membership is.
  • Maintaining the members' list, yes...determining who is a member, no...that should be up to a "legal" committee of sorts. And the number shouldn't be fixed...I think 3 may not be enough to do the job later on.
  • yes but it needs to be appointed by the chair rather than elected.
  • I fail to see the need for a policing of membership.
  • this needs distance


Last update 14 April, 2003. Questions, proposals or feedback about the website can be directed to the webmaster.


Graphics and code provided by Imachination Ltd.